Carini’S Pizza

I am all about supporting small businesses. This place is take out only, and only open Tuesday-Saturday, kind of hidden. If you're just passing by, you'd think they are close. After covid, they've never opened their dining room again. But for a small town, it's definitely worth a try, though. Great food, big portion. Fish fry wed and fri only. Wings are crispy and so flavorful. They make their own dough, not only for pizza, calzone, or stromboli, but for their sandwiches, bread, and croutons. Old school style, call for your order, go pick it up and grab a paper menu and keep it around, coz you're gonna wanna keep ordering food from there.

- Jenn -

This is not a chain restaurant that has a fairly diverse menu and comfort food. During my visit they had an all you can eat fish special running. I often for a single piece of fish. I was entitled to have two sides. I chose the salad and macaroni and cheese. Both the fish and the sides were excellent. The homemade bread was put on the table in significant quantity and it was also excellent. The staff was very friendly and the kept my ice tea refilled before, during and after the meal. I would high rate this restaurant and eat there anytime.

- hwileyiii -

Looking for Italian based menue, that is what you will find here. Servings are plentiful, prices are in line for food offered. They offer fish two days a week which is good and should be offered every day. Staff did a fine job and were very attentive. Nothing fancy, just good!

- Big Guy Guy -

I miss the Greenville location. I wish they delivered again, but they have great service and amazing food. It's a little pricey, but totally worth it. The large portions normally feed us twice.

- Jessica Torok -

First time eating in. Great people! Very friendly. Food was excellent. Very large portions (half orders are good size too) homemade bread! Delish! We will be back!

- Kathleen Roberts -

Small parking area but otherwise it's great. On par with the other locations in Jamestown and Greenville. Their bread is fantastic. Staff seems friendly, food portioned and priced week and always tasty.

- Jason Gruber -

Carini's has the best Alfredo sauce and the best homemade baked bread, which you get with the dinners AND they use it to make their hoagies. Everything here has been exceptional so far. I have not been disappointed yet. It is well worth a visit!

- Marsha Miller -

Excellent Italian food. My only complaint (in terms of food) is that the pizza does not exceed expectations. Subs, Wedges(^_^), Pasta, Soup: All exceptional. Yum ^_^ Excellent Italian decor, moderate service.

- Abe Johnson -